Quick Take
When you're sizing up powersports parts accessories, the first split is between routine filter swaps and bigger breather or fuel-delivery work. The four items here span listed prices from $11.99 to $67.99: an ATV oil filter, a Harley-Davidson oil filter, an aluminum engine breather oil catch can, and a Honda Rancher/Foreman carburetor kit. Start with the job you're doing and the exact model you're working on. That will tell you whether a quick oil-filter replacement is enough or whether you need a catch can or carburetor kit. That means checking the part number against your bike or ATV before you order, since none of these is listed as a universal fit.
Listed Price Comparison
| Product | Listed Price | Price Bar |
|---|---|---|
| Aluminum 40-0568 Engine Breather Oil Catch Can Collector | USD 44.99 | |
| HiFlo Oil Filter HF173C Harley Davidson | USD 14.95 | |
| QUAD ONE ATV REPLACEMENT PARTS #1300 Oil Filter | USD 11.99 | |
| Carburetor Kit for Honda Rancher 350 & Foreman ATV - Replacement Parts, Oil & Ai | USD 67.99 |
Decision Matrix
| Product | Choose it for | Avoid it for |
|---|---|---|
| Aluminum Catch Can | Catching oil mist from a breather hose on Harley, BMW, or Indian models. | A basic oil change where a filter is all you need. |
| HiFlo HF173C | A dedicated Harley-Davidson Dyna/FXR oil filter. | ATV applications. |
| Quad One #1300 | An ATV oil filter with listed Polaris, Honda, and Kawasaki fitment. | Carburetor or fuel-delivery work. |
| Carburetor Kit | A replacement carburetor for Honda Rancher 350/Foreman models. | A simple filter-only maintenance pass. |
Product Notes
Aluminum 40-0568 Engine Breather Oil Catch Can Collector
This catch can is designed to collect oil mist from the breather hose and keep engine oil out of the air cleaner. It has a high-flow air filter on top, a drain plug on the bottom, a 90° barbed fitting, and a chrome mounting billet clamp, and it is listed for Harley, BMW, and Indian models. At USD 44.99, it is the mid-price option in this group. The limitation is its purpose: it is not a replacement filter, so if you are doing routine oil maintenance, this addresses a different part of the system.
HiFlo Oil Filter HF173C Harley Davidson
At USD 14.95, the HiFlo HF173C is a dedicated oil filter for Harley-Davidson applications, with a listed fitment that includes multiple Dyna models plus FXR models. It is a straightforward filter choice if your bike is in that family. The limitation is scope: this listing is centered on Harley-Davidson Dyna/FXR fitment, so it will not be the right part for an ATV. Compare it with the Quad One filter only if you are cross-shopping a Harley-compatible filter versus an ATV filter.
QUAD ONE ATV REPLACEMENT PARTS #1300 Oil Filter
The Quad One #1300 is the lowest listed price in this group at USD 11.99. It is an ATV oil filter listed as compatible with Polaris, Honda, and Kawasaki machines, and the part number is 1300. The detailed fitment list includes many Honda ATC and TRX models, so you should match your specific ATV before ordering. The limitation is that it is only an oil filter; it will not help if you are chasing a carburetor problem or breather-hose oil mist.
Carburetor Kit for Honda Rancher 350 & Foreman ATV - Replacement Parts, Oil & Ai
At USD 67.99, this is the most expensive item in the group because it is a carburetor kit rather than a filter. It is listed for Honda Rancher 350 and Foreman ATV models, including TRX350FE, TRX350ES, TRX350FM, TRX350TM, TRX350TE, TRX450FE, and TRX450FM. The listing describes it as high-performance and says it is designed to help the ATV fire up without long warm-ups. The limitation is fitment: it is not a universal carburetor, so you need to confirm your exact Honda TRX model before committing.
Final Recommendation by Use Case
If your priority is a low-priced ATV oil filter with listed Polaris, Honda, or Kawasaki compatibility, choose the Quad One #1300. If you ride a Harley-Davidson Dyna or FXR and want a dedicated oil filter, the HiFlo HF173C is the match. When you are dealing with breather-hose oil mist on a Harley, BMW, or Indian, the Aluminum 40-0568 Engine Breather Oil Catch Can Collector fits that job. And when your Honda Rancher 350 or Foreman needs a replacement carburetor, the Carburetor Kit for Honda Rancher 350 & Foreman ATV is the part to consider. With listed prices from $11.99 to $67.99, the right pick depends on your model and the specific maintenance task.
