Choosing a service part for your powersports vehicle usually comes down to matching the part to your specific machine and deciding how much simple maintenance you want to take on. The four parts here cover very different jobs: one is a drop-in oil filter for Harley-Davidson models, another is an ATV oil filter with a long Honda fitment list, one is a rebuild kit for Harley EFI fuel check valves, and the last is a breather oil catch can for custom fitment across Harley, Indian, and BMW. Prices span $11.99 to $44.99, so the real question is which task matters first.
Quick Take
If you need a straightforward oil change filter for a Harley, the HiFlo HF173C is listed with fitment for a range of Dyna and FXR models. If you're working on an ATV, the QUAD ONE #1300 oil filter has the lowest listed price and covers many Honda TRX/ATC models in its description. For 2001-2014 Harley EFI models with a fuel check valve problem, the POSENG MC400 rebuild kit includes O-rings, springs, and installation hooks. And if you want to collect breather oil mist before it reaches the air cleaner, the lenkdou aluminum catch can comes with a high-flow air filter and drain plug.
Listed Price Comparison
| Product | Listed price | Price bar | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| HiFlo HF173C Oil Filter | USD 14.95 | Harley Dyna/FXR oil changes | |
| QUAD ONE #1300 Oil Filter | USD 11.99 | Honda ATV oil changes | |
| POSENG MC400 Rebuild Kit | USD 28.79 | 2001-2014 Harley EFI check valve service | |
| lenkdou 40-0568 Catch Can | USD 44.99 | Oil mist collection on Harley/Indian/BMW |
Decision Matrix
| If you need... | Choose... |
|---|---|
| A Harley oil filter for Dyna/FXR applications | HiFlo HF173C |
| An economical ATV oil filter for many Honda models | QUAD ONE #1300 |
| Parts to rebuild a Harley EFI fuel check valve | POSENG MC400 kit |
| A breather oil catch can for custom fitment | lenkdou 40-0568 |
Product Notes
HiFlo Oil Filter HF173C Harley Davidson
If you ride a Harley-Davidson Dyna or FXR from the generations listed in the product description, this HiFlo filter is built around those engine platforms. The listing states fitment for models like the Dyna Convertible, Low Rider, Wide Glide, and FXR 2/3/4. It is listed as new old stock, and the condition is noted as new other (see details), so inspect the photos and description before ordering. The filter type is straightforward: a replacement oil filter. The limitation is that it's aimed at a specific Harley range, not at ATVs or other makes. If your bike is on that fitment list, the HF173C gives a matching replacement part for that listed fitment.
QUAD ONE ATV REPLACEMENT PARTS #1300 Oil Filter
Listed as a new ATV oil filter, the QUAD ONE #1300 calls out a lengthy Honda ATV fitment list in the description, including ATC250ES, TRX250EX, TRX300, TRX400EX, TRX420, and TRX500 series models. The attributes also list Polaris, Honda, and Kawasaki as compatible makes, though the detailed model list is Honda-focused. That makes it a candidate for a Honda ATV oil change, but you should still compare the list to your exact machine. The limitation is that this is an ATV part, so it is not positioned for street motorcycles or the Harley/Indian/BMW crowd. If your model is on that list, the #1300 covers the filter task.
MC400 Fuel Tool Fuel Check Valve Rebuild Kit For 2001-2014 Harley Davidson EFI
The POSENG MC400 kit is a service part rather than a simple replacement. It targets 2001-2014 Harley-Davidson EFI fuel-injected models and includes five large and five small Viton O-rings, five stainless steel springs, five large and five small installation hooks, and the MC-400 installation tool, according to the description. That's a complete set if you are doing a check valve rebuild without removing the fuel tank. The limitation is fitment: it is for EFI models only, not carbureted engines, and the compatible make is listed as For Harley 2001-2014. The steel construction and one-year manufacturer warranty are listed details, but the part is specialized rather than universal.
Aluminum 40-0568 Engine Breather Oil Catch Can Collector For Harley BMW Indian
This lenkdou catch can handles a different job: collecting oil mist from the breather hose before it reaches the air cleaner. The description says it includes a high-flow air filter that acts as a baffle, a drain plug for regular drainage, a 90-degree barbed fitting, and a chrome mounting billet clamp. The color is black, and the title specifies aluminum construction. Fitment is described as custom fit for Harley, Indian, and BMW models, so check your particular bike rather than assuming model-specific coverage. The limitation is that it does not do oil filtration like the other two filters; it is an accessory-style collector for breather systems.
Final Recommendation by Use Case
Choose by job first. For a Harley Dyna/FXR oil change, the HiFlo HF173C matches the listed bike range. For a Honda ATV oil change, the QUAD ONE #1300 is the ATV-specific filter with a long Honda model list. For a 2001-2014 Harley EFI fuel check valve rebuild, the POSENG MC400 kit includes the O-rings, springs, hooks, and tool. For oil mist collection on a Harley, Indian, or BMW, the lenkdou 40-0568 catch can comes with its air filter and drain plug. Each part fills a distinct niche, so let your machine and the task decide.
